Casa

>

blog

>

Compostable vs Biodegradable Labels: What's the Difference & Which Should You Choose?

Compostable vs Biodegradable Labels: What’s the Difference & Which Should You Choose?

Condividere:

Sommario

Every brand wants to claim “eco-friendly,” but the terms compostable and biodegradable are not interchangeable.

UN 2024 study by the Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) found that non-compostable “lookalike” products are now the leading cause of contamination at US industrial composting facilities. Meanwhile, four US states have made it illegal to use “biodegradable” as a marketing claim on single-use products.

This guide breaks down the scientific definitions, certification requirements, opzioni materiali, and real-world applications so you can choose the right label for your product and market.

Compostable vs Biodegradable Core Difference

Eco Friendly & Naturale
Eco Friendly & Naturale

What Does “Biodegradable” Mean?

Biodegradable describes any material that can be broken down by microorganisms — bacteria, fungi, algae — into water, carbon dioxide, and biomass. The key limitation is that the term carries no guaranteed timeframe. A biodegradable label might decompose in three months or three years, depending on the environment, temperature, and moisture levels.

The word is broad and largely unregulated for marketing purposes. In technical contexts, “biodegradation” is simply the name for the process of microorganisms consuming organic carbon in a material. It is an important test criterion in compostability standards, but by itself, it tells you nothing about how fast or under what conditions the breakdown occurs.

What Does “Compostable” Mean?

Compostable is a stricter, more specific subset of biodegradable. A compostable label must decompose within a defined timeframe — typically 180 days or fewer in industrial composting, and up to 360 days in home composting — under controlled conditions of temperature, humidity, and microbial activity. The end product must be nutrient-rich humus with zero toxic residue.

The distinction matters because all compostable materials are technically biodegradable, but not all biodegradable materials are compostable. A material can be biodegradable in the sense that it will eventually break down, yet fail every compostability test because it takes too long, leaves microplastic fragments, or releases harmful substances during decomposition.

The Three Deciding Factors

Three criteria separate compostable from biodegradable in practice:

Criteria Biodegradable Compostable
Timeframe Unspecified (months to years) ≤180 days (industrial) / ≤360 days (home)
Conditions Any environment Controlled composting (temperature, humidity, microbes)
End products Water, CO₂, biomass — may leave micro-residues Water, CO₂, humus — zero toxic residue
Certification No universal standard EN 13432, ASTM D6400, OK Compost, BPI
Marketing claim Restricted in some US states and EU markets Safe and preferred term when certified

Why the Distinction Matters for Label Buyers

Legal and Regulatory Risk

In the United States, California, Washington, Minnesota, and Maryland have made it illegal to use “biodegradable” as a marketing claim on single-use products. The FTC Green Guides warn that unqualified biodegradable claims are deceptive if the product will not fully decompose within one year in a landfill — which most materials cannot do.

In the European Union, the Green Claims Directive (2024/825) requires substantiated evidence for any environmental claim. Vague terms like “eco-friendly” or “biodegradable” without supporting data can trigger enforcement action. Using the wrong term on your product label is not just misleading — it is a legal liability.

Compost Facility Contamination

BPI identifies “lookalike” products, items marketed as biodegradable but not actually compostable — as a leading cause of contamination at industrial composting facilities. When a non-compostable label ends up in the compost stream, it can leave microplastic fragments that compromise the entire batch. For brands selling into organic-certified or zero-waste markets, this represents a serious brand-reputation risk.

Consumer Trust and Certification Signals

Modern consumers actively check for certification logos. A BPI or OK Compost stamp on your label signals third-party verified credibility. A vague “biodegradable” claim without certification invites skepticism. Brands that invest in proper certification earn the trust of environmentally conscious buyers and retail partners who require documentation.

For a broader overview of all eco-friendly label material types, see our complete guide to sustainable label materials.

Certification Standards for Compostable & Biodegradable Labels

Unlike generic biodegradable claims, compostable labels are governed by rigorous international standards. Each major market has its own preferred certification, and your label supplier should be able to provide test reports for your target region.

Major Certifications Compared

Certification Region Standard Key Requirements Timeline
EN 13432 EU European standard ≥90% biodegradation in 6 months; disintegration in 12 weeks; no ecotoxicity 3–6 months testing
ASTM D6400 US / North America ASTM International ≥90% biodegradation in 180 days; 90% disintegration through 2mm sieve; heavy metal limits 3–6 months testing
BPI Certified US Based on ASTM D6400/D6868 Independent third-party testing; PFAS-free requirement; clear labeling 12+ months full process
OK Compost Industrial Global TÜV AUSTRIA, based on EN 13432 Same as EN 13432; widely recognized in EU and international markets 3–6 months testing
OK Compost Home Global TÜV AUSTRIA Must decompose at ambient temperature (≤30°C) within 12 months Longer testing cycle
Seedling Logo EU European Bioplastics Requires full EN 13432 compliance; high retail recognition in Europe Via certified body

ASTM D6868: The Label-Specific Standard

For labels specifically, ASTM D6868 is the most directly relevant standard. It covers compostable plastics coated on paper or other compostable substrates which describes most pressure-sensitive labels with compostable face stocks. If your label has a PLA (polylactic acid) coating on kraft paper, D6868 is the applicable test method.

The standard requires that the combined label material — face stock, adesivo, and any coatings — must meet the same biodegradation, disintegration, and ecotoxicity thresholds as standalone compostable materials. This whole-product testing approach is what makes D6868 certification meaningful.

For more details on BPI’s certification process and requirements, visit BPI’s official website.

Compostable Label Materials: What’s Available

Face Stock Options

Compostable label face stocks fall into several established categories:

PLA (Polylactic Acid) Films — Made from fermented corn starch or sugarcane, PLA films are available in transparent and white versions. They offer smooth printing surfaces comparable to conventional plastic films and are suitable for industrial composting. PLA is the most widely used compostable film in label applications.

Bagasse (Sugarcane Fiber) — A textured, natural brown material made from the fibrous residue left after sugarcane juice extraction. Bagasse labels have an organic, earthy appearance that works well for natural product branding. They are compatible with flexographic and digital printing using soy-based inks.

Bamboo Fiber — Similar to bagasse in appearance and compostability, bamboo fiber labels offer a slightly different texture profile. Bamboo grows faster than sugarcane, making it an attractive feedstock for brands emphasizing rapid renewable sourcing.

Cotton-Based Paper — Made from textile industry waste or cotton linters, these papers offer a soft white finish with excellent print quality. They are compostable in both industrial and some home composting settings.

PCW (Post-Consumer Waste) Recycled Paper — While 100% recycled paper is not technically “compostable” due to potential ink and contaminant variables, it represents a strong eco-friendly option with curbside recyclability. It is an excellent choice for brands that prioritize waste reduction over compostability certification.

The Adhesive Layer: Often Overlooked, Always Critical

The adhesive layer is the component most likely to undermine a label’s compostability. A truly compostable label requires a vegan, water-based, biodegradable adhesive — conventional pressure-sensitive adhesives contain synthetic polymers that leave microplastic residue after decomposition.

Many products marketed as “compostable labels” fail certification because the adhesive layer is not compostable. Leading suppliers now offer compostable hot-melt and acrylic adhesives that meet EN 13432 and ASTM D6400 requirements. When evaluating suppliers, always ask for the adhesive specification sheet, not just the face stock certification.

The Release Liner: Completing the System

The release liner — the backing paper that protects the adhesive until application — is the third component. Traditional silicone-coated PET liners are not compostable. Emerging alternatives include glassine paper liners (curbside recyclable) and compostable cellulose liners. For a fully compostable label system, all three layers must be certified or verified compostable.

Biodegradable-Only Label Options

Some materials carry biodegradable claims without meeting compostable standards:

EPI Additive-Treated Plastics — These contain oxo-degradable additives that cause conventional plastic to fragment into smaller pieces over time. They do not biodegrade completely and are banned from compost streams. The European Union has prohibited oxo-degradable plastics under the Single-Use Plastics Directive.

Bio-Based PE (Polyethylene) — Made from sugarcane ethanol, bio-based PE is chemically identical to petroleum-based PE. It does not compost, despite being derived from renewable resources. It is recyclable in the PE stream but should not be marketed as compostable.

Unspecified “Biodegradable” Films — Products that claim biodegradability without stating a timeframe or environment represent a high greenwashing risk. Buyers should treat any biodegradable claim without third-party certification as unverified.

How to Choose: A Decision Framework for Brands

The choice between compostable and biodegradable labels depends on four factors: your product’s end-of-life environment, your target market’s regulatory requirements, your brand’s sustainability positioning, and your budget.

Decision Matrix

Scenario Recommended Label Reason
Product enters organic waste stream (food packaging, compostable bags) Compostable (EN 13432 / ASTM D6400) Must not contaminate compost stream
Selling into EU or California market Compostable with certification Legal requirements for environmental claims
Natural/organic cosmetics brand Compostable (OK Compost or BPI) Consumer expectation and certification trust signal
General retail product, no composting infrastructure Biodegradable (with proper qualification) Acceptable if qualified; avoid unqualified “100% biodegradable”
Candle jars, glass bottles (recyclable container) Recyclable or biodegradable label Container likely enters recycling, not compost; see our candle label guide
Budget-conscious, large-volume run PCW recycled paper + inchiostri di soia Cost-effective, recyclable, strong eco-story without compostable premium

Understanding the Cost Difference

Compostable labels typically cost 15–40% more than standard biodegradable options. The premium comes from certification fees, specialized material sourcing, smaller production runs, and the cost of compostable adhesives and liners.

The premium is justified when: (a) your product enters the compost stream, (b) your target retailer requires certification, or (c) your brand positioning demands third-party verified claims. For products where the label will be separated before disposal — such as a label on a glass bottle that enters the recycling stream — a well-qualified biodegradable or recyclable option may be the more appropriate choice.

Printing & Customization Options for Eco Labels

Printing Method Compatibility

Both compostable and biodegradable labels support standard printing methods, with some material-specific considerations:

Flexographic Printing — Works well on both PLA films and natural fiber stocks like bagasse and bamboo. This is the preferred method for medium to large production runs. Soy-based and vegetable-based inks are the industry standard for eco labels, drying brilliantly on porous surfaces.

Digital Printing — Ideal for short runs, variable data, and prototype sampling. Compatible with most compostable face stocks. Digital printing allows you to test designs before committing to larger flexographic runs.

Offset Printing — Best suited for large-volume runs on paper-based stocks. Offers the highest color fidelity for complex designs with multiple spot colors.

Soy and Vegetable-Based Inks — These have become the industry standard for eco labels of all types. They dry well on porous surfaces like bagasse, bamboo fiber, and kraft paper, and they do not introduce petroleum-derived compounds into the compost stream.

For more on how different label materials interact with printing processes, see our kraft paper labels guide.

Finishing Constraints for Eco Labels

Eco labels have different finishing options compared to conventional labels:

No Conventional Lamination — Plastic laminates make labels non-compostable and non-recyclable. Water-based coatings are the alternative, providing moisture and scuff resistance without compromising end-of-life options.

Blind Embossing — Creates three-dimensional texture through mechanical pressure alone, with zero ink or chemicals. This is the ultimate eco-luxury finish — it adds tactile sophistication without any environmental cost.

No Metallic Foils — Traditional hot-stamp foils contain non-compostable metals and plastic carriers. If foil effects are essential, discuss compostable foil alternatives with your supplier, though options remain limited.

UV Spot Coating — Partially compatible with compostable systems. Check with your supplier for specific product data, as some UV coatings may affect compostability certification.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Based on industry experience, these are the most frequent errors brands make when sourcing eco labels:

  1. Using “biodegradable” as a marketing claim without qualification. This is illegal in four US states and violates FTC Green Guides. Use “compostable” with certification instead.
  2. Ignoring the adhesive layer. A compostable face stock paired with conventional adhesive is not a compostable label. All three layers — face stock, adesivo, and liner — must be certified.
  3. Assuming “bio-based” means compostable. Bio-based PE from sugarcane is chemically identical to petroleum PE. It does not compost. Source origin does not determine end-of-life behavior.
  4. Skipping market-specific certification. EN 13432 covers the EU market. ASTM D6400 covers North America. AS 4736 covers Australia. One certification does not automatically cover all markets.
  5. Using compostable labels on recyclable containers. If your product jar enters the recycling stream, a compostable label is wasted cost. Match the label to the actual end-of-life pathway.
  6. Providing no end-of-life instructions for consumers. Even certified compostable labels need clear disposal guidance. Include instructions like “Remove before recycling” or “Place in industrial compost bin” to ensure proper handling.

Domande frequenti: Compostable & Biodegradable Labels

Can a label be both compostable and biodegradable?

SÌ. All compostable materials are technically biodegradable — composting is simply a specific, controlled form of biodegradation with defined timeframes and conditions. A certified compostable label is always biodegradable by definition. However, a biodegradable label is not necessarily compostable unless it meets specific certification standards.

How long does it take for a compostable label to decompose?

Under industrial composting conditions (58–60°C, controlled humidity, active microbial populations), certified compostable labels must decompose within 180 days per EN 13432 and ASTM D6400 standards. In home composting conditions (ambient temperature, natural microbial activity), the timeframe extends to 12 months or longer, depending on the specific material and certification.

Are biodegradable labels safe for food packaging?

Biodegradable labels can be safe for food packaging, but safety depends on the specific materials and inks used. For direct food contact, labels must comply with FDA (US) or EFSA (EU) food-contact regulations regardless of whether they are biodegradable or compostable. Compostable certification provides additional assurance that the label will not leave harmful residues.

What’s the difference between industrial compostable and home compostable?

Industrial compostable labels require the elevated temperatures (58–60°C), controlled humidity, and specific microbial populations found in commercial composting facilities. They decompose within 180 days under these conditions. Home compostable labels must decompose at ambient temperatures (typically ≤30°C) using natural microbial activity, usually within 12 months. Home compostable is a stricter standard because the conditions are less controlled.

Can I print custom designs on compostable labels?

SÌ. Compostable labels support flexographic, digital, and offset printing with soy-based or vegetable-based inks. You can achieve full-color custom designs, variable data, and complex graphics on compostable face stocks including PLA films, bagasse, bamboo fiber, and cotton-based papers.

Do compostable labels cost more than regular labels?

Compostable labels typically cost 15–40% more than conventional labels. The premium comes from certification fees, specialized compostable materials (face stock, adesivo, and liner), and smaller production runs. The cost gap narrows with larger volumes and when you factor in the marketing and compliance value of certification.

How do I verify a supplier’s compostable claims?

Request third-party test reports for EN 13432, ASTM D6400, or ASTM D6868. Ask for the certification body name and certificate number — you can verify these on the BPI database (for US market) or TÜV AUSTRIA’s OK Compost registry (for international markets). A legitimate supplier will provide complete material composition breakdowns for all three label layers.

Sourcing Compostable Labels: What to Ask Your Supplier

When evaluating compostable label suppliers, request the following documentation:

Third-party test reports for EN 13432, ASTM D6400, or the relevant standard for your target market. These should cover the complete label assembly — face stock, adesivo, and liner — not just individual components.

Certification body name and certificate number, verifiable on the BPI or TÜV AUSTRIA online database. This confirms the certification is current and has not been revoked.

Complete material composition breakdown showing each component’s compostability status. If the supplier cannot provide this for all three layers, the label is unlikely to be fully compostable.

Shelf life and storage recommendations. Compostable materials have shorter shelf life than conventional labels — typically 12–18 months when stored in cool, dry conditions. Proper storage prevents premature degradation.

Minimum order quantities and lead times. Compostable materials are often made to order, with MOQs typically higher than conventional labels and lead times of 3–5 weeks. Plan your production schedule accordingly.

Making the Right Choice

Choosing between compostable and biodegradable labels is not just an environmental decision — it is a regulatory, marketing, and supply-chain decision. The right choice depends on your product’s end-of-life path, your target market’s requirements, and your brand’s sustainability story.

The brands that get this right earn genuine consumer trust, avoid regulatory pitfalls, and contribute meaningfully to waste reduction. The brands that cut corners with vague claims risk fines, contamination issues, and reputational damage.

Explore our full range of eco-friendly and natural labels or read the complete guide to sustainable label materials for more options across all material types.

If recycled content matters to your sustainability program, our guide to recycled paper labels with PCW content explains how the percentages are verified.

Eric Zhang

Head of International Business Eric Zhang is the Head of International Business at our company, bringing over 5 years of hands-on experience in the custom labels and packaging industry. He specializes in delivering high-quality, innovative packaging solutions to global clients, with a strong focus on market expansion and understanding customer needs to help brands create distinctive product identities.

Mettiti in contatto

Blog popolari

It seems we can't find what you're looking for.

Scalabilità con personalizzazione del packaging di fascia alta

Dalle complesse etichette adesive alle scatole rigide strutturali, garantiamo una qualità costante per marchi globali e agenzie commerciali.

Contattaci

*Rispettiamo la tua riservatezza e tutte le informazioni sono protette.

Non sei sicuro di quale materiale sia adatto al tuo marchio?

L’ingegneria del packaging può essere complessa. Lascia il tuo messaggio, e i nostri progettisti strutturali offriranno una consulenza individuale gratuita per trovare la soluzione economicamente vantaggiosa perfetta per il tuo prodotto.

Contattaci

*Rispettiamo la tua riservatezza e tutte le informazioni sono protette.